Journal of Art and Civilization of the Orient

An Introduction to the Views of Traditionalists on Islamic Art and Architecture through the Critique of Titus Burckhardt

https://doi.org/10.22034/jaco.2024.448039.1407
Volume 12, Issue 45
Autumn 2024
Pages 48-59
Journal of Art and Civilization of the Orient

Document Type : Research Paper

Author

Shohreh Javadi

Assistant Professor, Department of Advanced Studies of Art, School of Visual Arts, Faculty of Fine Arts, University of Tehran, Iran.

Abstract
Most traditionalist thinkers, influenced by Sufi Islam and emphasizing the mystical aspects, believe in a shared and universal supernatural truth inherent in religious traditions. This intellectual movement, initiated by René Guénon and carried forward by figures such as Titus Burckhardt, Frithjof Schuon, Ananda Coomaraswamy, and Martin Lings, has significantly influenced contemporary comparative theology. Within the Islamic world, it intertwines with mystical currents and Eastern religious practices. These theorists express their views through Islamic architecture and art, employing illogical and emotional arguments that have led to confusion and disorder in Iran’s cultural and artistic community for many years. Critiquing Burckhardt’s views on the theoretical foundations of art and the manifestations of Islamic art and architecture reveals a tendency towards sanctification and a retreat from rationality, aiming to offer a realistic and logical assessment of the arts in the Islamic world. Traditionalists, emphasizing perennial wisdom, hold a belief in a fixed, sacred, and esoteric tradition across all human religions, perceiving a common tradition in Islam, Christianity, Judaism, and Eastern Asian religions. Unfortunately, their definition of tradition diverges significantly from the Islamic understanding found in the Holy Quran, leading to gross misinterpretations and unscientific interpretations in various fields, particularly in Islamic art and architecture. 

Keywords

Traditionalists
Critique
Burckhardt
Art
Islamic Architecture
• Avini, M. (1993). Pishgoftar [Foreword]. In A. Tajodini (Ed.), Mabani-ye honar-e manavi: majmo’e-e maghalat  (Henry Corbin, Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burckhardt, Ananda Coomaraswamy va T. D. Suzuki) [Fundamentals of spiritual art: a collection of articles (Henry Corbin, Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burckhardt, Ananda Coomaraswamy & T. D. Suzuki) (Vol. 1) (pp. 9-10). Daftar-e Motale’at-e Dini-ye Honar [Office of Religious Studies of Art].
• Bakan, A. (2021). A Critical Review and Analysis on the Structure and Content of the Article Entitled: “Formation of Space as a Result of Conceptual Alignment of Music-Math and Architecture” Case study: The entrance and Dome Shaped Roof of Sheikh Lotfollah Mosque Isfahan. Journal of Art and Civilization of the Orient, 9(33), 11-20. https://doi.org/10.22034/jaco.2021.300931.1213
• Burckhardt, T. (1993a). Nazari be osol va falsafe-ye honar-e Islami [A comment on the principles and philosophy of Islamic art. In A. Tajodini (Ed.), Mabani-ye honar-e manavi: majmo’e-e maghalat (Henry Corbin, Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burckhardt, Ananda Coomaraswamy va T. D. Suzuki) [Fundamentals of spiritual art: a collection of articles (Henry Corbin, Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burckhardt, Ananda Coomaraswamy & T. D. Suzuki) (Vol. 1) (pp. 31-50). Daftar-e Motale’at-e Dini-ye Honar [Office of Religious Studies of Art]. [in persian] (original work published 1976)
• Burckhardt, T. (1993b). The spirit of Islamic art. In A. Tajodini (Ed.), Mabani-ye honar-e manavi: majmo’e-e maghalat (Henry Corbin, Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burckhardt, Ananda Coomaraswamy va T. D. Suzuki) [Fundamentals of spiritual art: a collection of articles (Henry Corbin, Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burckhardt, Ananda Coomaraswamy & T. D. Suzuki) (Vol. 1) (pp. 51-61). Daftar-e Motale’at-e Dini-ye Honar [Office of Religious Studies of Art]. [in persian] (original work published 1954)
• Burckhardt, T. (1993c). Arzeshha-ye javidan-e honar-e Islami [The Perennial Values in Islamic Art]. In A. Tajodini (Ed.), Mabani-ye honar-e manavi: majmo’e-e maghalat  (Henry Corbin, Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burckhardt, Ananda Coomaraswamy va T. D. Suzuki) [Fundamentals of spiritual art: a collection of articles (Henry Corbin, Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burckhardt, Ananda Coomaraswamy & T. D. Suzuki) (Vol. 1) (pp. 63-77). Daftar-e Motale’at-e Dini-ye Honar [Office of Religious Studies of Art]. [in persian]
• Burckhardt, T. (1993d). madkhali bar osol va ravesh-e honar-e dini [An Introduction to the Principles and Methods of Religious Art]. In A. Tajodini (Ed.), Mabani-ye honar-e manavi: majmo’e-e maghalat (Henry Corbin, Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burckhardt, Ananda Coomaraswamy va T. D. Suzuki) [Fundamentals of spiritual art: a collection of articles (Henry Corbin, Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burckhardt, Ananda Coomaraswamy & T. D. Suzuki) (Vol. 1) (pp. 79-87). Daftar-e Motale’at-e Dini-ye Honar [Office of Religious Studies of Art]. [in persian]
• Burckhardt, T. (2008). Foundations of Islamic Art (A. Nasri, Trans.). Haghighat. [in persian] (original work published 1967).
• Burckhardt, T. (2011). Sacred Art (J. Satari, Trans.). Soroush. [in persian] (original work published 1967)
• Eskandarpour Khorrami, P. (2018). Eslimi va neshanha [Arabesque & symbols]. Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance.
• Ghanbari, H. (2016). Emkan va zarorat-e honar-e Islami, barresi va naghd-e didgah-e sonatgarayan [The possibility and necessity of Islamic art, review and criticism of traditionalists’ point of view]. Negah-e Moaser.
• Gray, B. (1995). La peinture persane [Persian Painting]. Skira. (original work published 1930)
• Javadi, S. (2004). Landscape in the Miniatures of Iran. Bagh-e Nazar, 1(1), 25-37. https://www.bagh-sj.com/article_1492.html?lang=fa
• Javadi, S. (2006). Study of the Art of safavid. Bagh-e Nazar, 3(5), 6-18. https://www.bagh-sj.com/article_76.html
• Khosraviyani, N., & Javadi, S. (2022). An Introduction to and Examination of Arabesque Motifs in the Decorations of Islamic Period (A critique of the book “Eslimi and Medallions ”). Journal of Art and Civilization of the Orient, 9(34), 15-28. https://doi.org/10.22034/jaco.2021.299546.1211
• Mansouri, S. A. & Javadi, Sh. (2020). The trilogy of Persian landscape: a study on the essence of Persian Architecture and urban space. Nazar Reserch Center for the Art, Architecture & Urbanism.
• Olyaee, S. V. (2021). Criticism of Traditionalists’ Ideas on Wisdom and Concealed Secrets of Islamic Art. Journal of Art and Civilization of the Orient, 9(33), 5-10. https://doi.org/10.22034/jaco.2021.290571.1205
• Rahnavard, Z. (1999). The of Islamic Art Wisdom. SAMT.
• Rashidi, S. (2017). Para Islamic Art: critical analysis of dominant discourses in Islamic Arts Studies. Elmi Farhangi. 
• Sajadi, A. (1997). Seyr-e tahavol-e mehrab dar me’mari-ye Islami-ye Iran az aghaz ta hamle-ye Mongols [The evolution of the mihrab in the Islamic architecture of Iran from the beginning to the Mongol invasion]. Ministry of Cultural Heritage  of County.
• Tajodini, A. (1993). Mabani-ye honar-e manavi: majmo’e-e maghalat (Henry Corbin, Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burckhardt, Ananda Coomaraswamy va T. D. Suzuki) [Fundamentals of spiritual art: a collection of articles (Henry Corbin, Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burckhardt, Ananda Coomaraswamy & T. D. Suzuki) (Vol. 1).  Daftar-e Motale’at-e Dini-ye Honar [Office of Religious Studies of Art].

Home

Submit Manuscript

Contact Us