Tradition Vs Modernity in the Mosques of Pakistan Revisited

Document Type : Research Paper

Author

Ph.D. in Architecture, Department of Architecture, South Branch, Islamic Azad University, NAZAR Research Center, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

Mosques unquestionably reflect the most significant aspect of religious architecture in the Islamic world. Shortly after the emergence of Islam, it was quickly embraced by numerous nations and had a profound impact on every aspect of people’s social and private lives. After the presence of Muslims, the Indian subcontinent was among the communities that were strongly influenced by Islam and its architecture changed. The purpose of this study is to examine the structure of traditional and contemporary mosques in Pakistan from a typological perspective to answer the following questions: a) what is the typology of traditional and contemporary mosques in Pakistan? b) How do traditional and modern architectural styles manifest themselves in the mosques? For this purpose, based on bibliographic resources, traditional mosques were identified and then five important mosques in Pakistan reflecting different traditional styles were selected. Similarly, five contemporary mosques and their characteristics were studied. Then, using an analytical-descriptive method, each case study was scrutinized, and the characteristics of each style were presented. Finally, through a comparative study, the features of traditionalism and modernism in the mosques of this country were investigated. The results showed that the architecture of Pakistani mosques underwent many changes in the transition from traditionalism to modernism, and the architectural styles of their mosques were subject to changes since the attitude and way of thinking of their architects were influenced by Western architecture. The traditional mosques of this country have two types of courtyards: a Shabestan with a courtyard and a four-iwan courtyard. Its modern mosques are of four types: formalist, purist, eclectic, and local. Moreover, it seems that contemporary Pakistani architects seek a new interpretation of the architectural elements of traditional mosques in the modern world. However, in most cases, they have not succeeded in this area and their architecture has completely separated tradition from modernity.

Keywords

References

  • Cansever, T. (2007). Kubbeyi Yere Koymamak. Istanbul: Timaş Yayınları.
  • Crystal, D. (2006). The Penguin Encylopedia. USA: Penguin Group.
  • Durmuş, S. (2009). A Deconstructionist Reading in Religious Spaces: Shah Faisal Mosque (Unpublished Master’s Thesis). Department of Architecture, Karadeniz Technical University, Trabzon, Turkey.
  • Fathi, E. & Rezazadeh Tameh, Gh. (1997). Masjed dar asr-e hazer [Mosque in the present age]. Honar va Me’mary, (33), 374-391.
  • Grube, J., Dickie, J., Grabar, O., Sims, E., Lewcock, R., Jones, D., Petherbridge, G.T. (1995). Architecture of the Islamic World: Its History and Social Meaning. London: Thumes & Hudson.
  • Gur, S. O. & Durmus, S. (2012). Deconstruction as a Mechanism of Creativity and its Reflections on Islamic Architecture. Architetoni, 1, 32-45.
  • Haj Seyyed Javadi, S.K. (2012). Study of Iranian’s Cultural, Artistic and Architectural Influence on the Construction of Khorasan Tomb at Lahore. Kimiya-ye-Honar, 1(1), 27-38.
  • Hajianpour, H. & Taheri, E. (2013). Naghsh-e masajed-e Hind dar eslampaziri va me’mari-ye Hendian [The role of Indian mosques in Islamization and Indian architecture]. Parseh, 13(21), 1-22.
  • Hassan-Al-Din Khan. (1997). Contemporary mosques (F. Sojoudi, Trans.). Honar va Me’mary, (33), 332-363.

Joghataei, A. & Faroughi, M.Y. (1972). Athar-e me’mari-ye eslami dar Pakeshtan-e bakhtari [Works of Islamic Architecture in West Pakistan]. Hilal, (123), 41-50.

  • Koch, E. (1982). The baluster column: An European motif in Moghul architecture and its meaninn, Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes, 45, 251-262.
  • Koch, E. (1991). Moghul Architecture: An Outline of Its History and Development. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  • Koch, E. (1991). The Mughal Architecture. Munich: Prestel Verlag.
  • Koch, E. (1994). Indian architecture in the Gurkhanid period (H. Soltanzadeh, Trans.). Tehran: Daftar-e Pajohesh-ha-ye Farhangi.
  • Mahdavinejad, M., Mashayekhi, M. & Bahrami, M. (2017). Mosque design pattern in contemporary architecture. Journal of Research in Islamic Architecture Iran University of Science & Technology, 2(5), 1-15.
  • Mousavi, S.M. (1965). Fan-e me’mary dar zaman-e emperatori-ye Teimourian-E Hin va Pakistan [Architecture during the Timurid Empire of India and Pakistan]. Vahid, (22), 53-63.
  • Mumtaz, K.K. (1985). Architecture in Pakistan (J. Shaw Ed.). Singapore: Concept Media.
  • Nath, R. (1982). History of Mughal Architecture: Babur & Humayun. Vol.1, Delhi: Abhinav Publishers.
  • Naz, N. (2005). Contribution of Turkish Architects to the National Architecture of Pakistan: Vedat Dalokay. METU JFA, 22(2), 51-77.
  • Parvin, H. (1997). Masajed-e shebhe ghare-ye Hind [Mosques of the Indian subcontinent]. Honar va Me’mary, (33), 186-221.
  • Pestersen, A. (1996). Dictionary of Islamic Architecture. New York: Routledge.
  • Pourjafar, M. (2002). Tavajoh be me’yar-ha-ye tarahi-ye shahri va me’mary dar masajed-e ghadimi: mored-e motale’e masjed-e jame’e Dehli [Attention to Urban Design and Architecture Criteria in Old Mosques: A Case Study of the Delhi Grand Mosque]. Farhang va Honar, (1), 75-90.
  • Pourjafar, M., Amirkahni, A. & Leylian, M. (2012). Contemporav modern mosques architecture. Tehran: Tahan.

.

Journal of Art and Civilization of the Orient
Volume 10, Issue 36
June 2022
Pages 55-70

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics